deepscientist-rebuttal - Coordinate evidence-based paper rebuttals
Maps reviewer feedback to evidence checks, experiments, manuscript revisions, claim adjustments, and response artifacts.
Tags
Updated: 2026-10-12Capabilities
Typical Inputs
Typical Outputs
What this skill does
- Normalize reviewer feedback
- Classify reviewer concerns
- Map concerns to actions
- Plan supplementary experiments
- Route manuscript revisions
- Assemble response letters
- Track claim adjustments
Inputs
- Current paper or draft
- Reviewer comments
- Meta-review or editor letter
- User-provided attachments
- Manuscript paths or URLs
- Evaluation summaries
- Experiment results
- Writing memory
- Claim-evidence maps
Outputs
- Review matrix file
- Action plan file
- Response letter file
- Text deltas file
- Evidence update file
- Experiment matrix files
- Reviewer-linked experiment logs
- Durable rebuttal artifacts
Requirements
- DeepScientist Codex native plugin
- Codex-native execution tools
- dsctl.py access
- DeepScientist project state
- Required manuscript and review access