peer-review - Systematically evaluate manuscripts and grant proposals
Evaluates scientific manuscripts and grant proposals for methodology, statistics, design, reproducibility, ethics, figure integrity, and reporting standards.
Tags
Updated: 2026-09-30peer reviewscientific manuscriptsgrant proposalsresearch methodologystatisticsreproducibilityresearch ethicsreporting standards
Capabilities
What this skill does
- Evaluate study methodology
- Assess statistical analyses
- Review experimental design
- Check reproducibility practices
- Verify ethical compliance
- Inspect figures and tables
- Assess reporting standards
- Review writing clarity
- Prioritize actionable feedback
Inputs
- Manuscript or grant proposal
- Figures and tables
- Methods and statistical details
- Data and code availability information
Outputs
- Peer review report
- Initial assessment summary
- Methodological and statistical assessment
- Prioritized constructive feedback