proposal-critic - Technical Proposal Review Critic
Review technical proposals and decision records with evidence-backed critique
Tags
Updated: 2026-05-09Capabilities
Typical Inputs
Typical Outputs
What this skill does
- review RFCs and ADRs
- critique migration plans
- evaluate architecture decisions
- assess feature specs
- perform pre-mortem analysis
- audit dependencies
- review refactor proposals
- extract key assumptions
- analyze rollback strategies
- identify ambiguities and gaps
Inputs
- RFC documents
- ADR documents
- migration plans
- architecture decisions
- feature specifications
- refactor proposals
- pre-implementation documents
Outputs
- review verdict
- findings report
- risk assessment
- ambiguity identification
- pre-mortem analysis
Requirements
- proposal documents
- review rubrics